Favourite aftershave(s)

Randomangle

Über Bum
Uncertain if I can get away with saying Saponificio Varesino, easily the most healing/nourishing aftershave I've used but it is quite a thick lotion... I can splash it on but it's stretching the definition a little. I like Speick, Pitralon & B&M Reserve etc but if we are talking purely about performance rather than scents I find them no better than good old Thayers witch hazel with aloe which is for me just as good, doesn't have a strong scent to interfere with your Cologne and is nicely inexpensive (£12/350ml.)
Are you still using the Thayers?

Concerning Tüff (anyone), where on earth can it be purchased? :confused:
 

Dr Watson

James
Are you still using the Thayers?

Concerning Tüff (anyone), where on earth can it be purchased? :confused:
I never replaced my bottle of Thayers when it ran out... found something else which I preferred, though not as good value. Mandom Lucido aftershave lotion from Japan, available on eBay for around £12 delivered. It's completely unscented and has a mild menthol hit.

As for Tüff I think the only place you can get it from outside of Germany is yourshaving.com - Probably the most underrated/overlooked aftershave in the world IMO :)
 

Randomangle

Über Bum
I never replaced my bottle of Thayers when it ran out... found something else which I preferred, though not as good value. Mandom Lucido aftershave lotion from Japan, available on eBay for around £12 delivered. It's completely unscented and has a mild menthol hit.

As for Tüff I think the only place you can get it from outside of Germany is yourshaving.com - Probably the most underrated/overlooked aftershave in the world IMO :)
Thanks James, a great help. I feel some spending coming on.
 

Zwilling

Kamisori shaver
I never replaced my bottle of Thayers when it ran out... found something else which I preferred, though not as good value. Mandom Lucido aftershave lotion from Japan, available on eBay for around £12 delivered. It's completely unscented and has a mild menthol hit.
I have been thinking about getting the Lucido - I am curious about it. Does it have any moisturising properties?
 

Dr Watson

James
I have been thinking about getting the Lucido - I am curious about it. Does it have any moisturising properties?
It feels like mentholated witch hazel to me so not particularly but there is a little. It's nothing like classic European aftershaves with their castor oil content which gives the skin a slick feeling... Lucido is probably closer to something like Fine.
 

Burgundy

Forum GOD!
Humphreys Lilac toner works well for me. I prefer my aftershaves alcohol-free and only lightly-fragranced with some skin ‘conditioning’ - this has allantoin, aloe, glycerin, hyaluronic acid, panthenol, calendula and a few other bits and pieces. I follow up with a dedicated moisturiser which, in my opinion, is a more important part of the routine!

Ingredients:
Filtered water, aloe barbadensis leaf juice*, hamamelis virginiana (witch hazel) water, vegetable glycerin, sodium PCA, hyaluronic acid, panthenol (pro-vitamin B5), allantoin, extracts of [arnica Montana* (arnica), calendula officinalis* (calendula), camellia sinensis* (white tea), aspalathus linearis (red tea), camellia sinensis (black tea), camellia sinensis (green tea), cucumis sativus (cucumber), carica papaya (papaya), ananas sativus (pineapple), hedychium coronarium (awaphui), althaea officinalis (marshmallow) root, dianthus superbus (lilac pink herb), curcuma longa (tumeric)], polysorbate 20, hydrogenated castor oil, phenoxyethanol (rose essence), ethyl hexyl glycerin, fragrance.
 

Zwilling

Kamisori shaver
It feels like mentholated witch hazel to me so not particularly but there is a little. It's nothing like classic European aftershaves with their castor oil content which gives the skin a slick feeling... Lucido is probably closer to something like Fine.
That's helpful, thanks!
 

Benz3ne

Forum GOD!
Recently procured bottles of mid-80’s Azzaro Pour Homme EdT and A/S. They’re both strongly scented but the A/S has been pleasantly surprising. Slick and alcoholic on skin and feels moisturising as it quickly dries. Has been nice post-shave and exacerbates the fragrance.
 
Last edited:

brothers

Forum GOD!
For about 3 or 4 years now, I've been using my favorite aftershave splash - Superior 70 Mentolado to which I add a generous amount of additional menthol crystals and 1/3 of a tube of 444 balm. Each bottle lasts 6 months. It's not a perfume, and I like how it feels following the shave. I'm not much of a fan of fragrance for the sake of smelling pretty in the office or elevator. :happy:
 

Dr Watson

James
As it’s so cheap I will have to have both (of course)!
Did you order any in the end Rando? I decided to restock myself and they arrived today in the new bottles. Used the red (herb) a little while ago and can tell you the scent is very similar to Proraso red aftershave, I'm almost certain its the same perfume used in them both it's that similar.
 
Top