Favourite aftershave(s)

[SkyWarrior21]

In no particular order:

PAA Star Jelly unscented (amazing for summer)
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails (amazing for winter)
PAA Mysterium Serum unscented
Proraso Lozione Dopobarba
The Stray Whisker After Balm
Stirling Iced Pineapple post-shave balm

 

[Steve Bowles]

My favourite post-shave balm was Musgo Real until it went up to a minimum of £38 for 100 ml.

 

[ManicDee]

My favourite post-shave balm was Musgo Real until it went up to a minimum of £38 for 100 ml.

Is that stuff any good? Always looked a bit over priced!

 

[Dr Watson]

My favourite post-shave balm was Musgo Real until it went up to a minimum of £38 for 100 ml.

Currently on sale at Shave Lounge

 

[ManicDee]

In no particular order:

PAA Star Jelly unscented (amazing for summer)
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails (amazing for winter)
PAA Mysterium Serum unscented
Proraso Lozione Dopobarba
The Stray Whisker After Balm
Stirling Iced Pineapple post-shave balm

SkyWarrior21, Can I ask where you bought the PAA products from?

 

[Grosser]

Proraso Green
Floid Vigoroso

 

[Beemers]

Pitralon classic, Royal Lyme, Myersol Blue, Pavo Rabanne, Antica Barbara Colla, aramis

 

[Beemers]

Australian Private Reserve splashes get a big nod from me.
I enjoyed Fine aftershaves despite the concise ingredients list.
Floïd Black and MV are both winners, especially with added menthol (yes, in both cases).

 

[Deleted member 1881]

Post shave balm: Natura Siberica
Post shave lotion: Floid, Proraso Red, Pinaud Clubman Gent's Gin, Felce Azzurra Uomo.

 

[MntnMan62]

In no particular order.

Splashes:
Pinaud Clubman
PC Lime Sec
PC Citrus Musk
PC Virgin Island Bay Rum
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Aqua Velva Musk
Murray & Lanman Florida Water
Razorock Blue Barbershop

Balms:
Taylor of Old Bond Street Mr. Taylor's Luxury Aftershave Balm

 

[Rufusdog]

On Tuesday I received a bottle of Fine American Blend Aftershave splash. I had not used this splash, or any Fine product, before so I was sailing into uncharted waters with this purchase; however, I did like the description of its scent and that it contains menthol. I’ve used it for the last 3 mornings and I’m very impressed. Will it become my favourite aftershave? We’ll see, but the competition is tough. My current favourite is Harris Arlington, which I’ve been using for years, and never tire of. Ultimately, it could be a tie between Arlington and American Blend, with Arlington being primus inter pares.

 

[Dr Watson]

I think Proraso red may be my new favourite splash... This is how I feel when sniffing the open bottle

 

[Shaverrific666]

I think Proraso red may be my new favourite splash... This is how I feel when sniffing the open bottle

View attachment 51311

Haha it's bloody good isn't it! I liked it so much I bought a big Barber's bottle . It's seems more moisturizing than the green.I love the green as well mind you.

 

[Dr Watson]

Haha it's bloody good isn't it! I liked it so much I bought a big Barber's bottle . It's seems more moisturizing than the green.I love the green as well mind you.

It's bloody bloody good Chris! I can see a 400ml bottle in my future too (already on my Amazon wishlist )

 

[Shaverrific666]

It's bloody bloody good Chris! I can see a 400ml bottle in my future too (already on my Amazon wishlist )

Gemstone have it James..it was the best price I saw for a while. Not sure what it's going for on Amazon..