For me they're both beautiful and lasting smells as well as an awesome performers, but still, not worth the money. It's only an aftershave....View attachment 47108
Wonderful smell, so-so performance and at £15 an OK price. These are now £25 ( in USD they have also gone up $10) and they are no longer worth the money.
Speick is half the price and twice the performance but nowhere near as nice smelling.
Focus man, focus!Finished????
I have 30 soaps - I don't finish ANYTHING!

Slicker than the Maca Root Old Formula?I finished a sample of Mystic Water Adirondack Jack. It was good but it didn't wow me enough to get a full tub of it. I moved on to MW's Barbershop. First shave was nice. The scent is similar though.
LOL. You're too funny. I haven't used the Maca Root in a while. I also don't want to comment on a comparison until I've had a chance to use the Mystic Water soap a few more times.Slicker than the Maca Root Old Formula?