Okay so there are three main recipes...
The "
original" which was supposed to be similar to MdC but isn't really. I found this superb for straight razor shaves actually but poor for safety razors.
The
original formula scents are:
Traditionnel, Cologne/Fougere, Cedre/Orange, Cedre/Patchouli, Nature, Barbershop & Abricot.
Next came the "limited edition" recipe which contains tallow and shea butter. The only scent in this is the Oud/Santal, I found it provided a slightly denser, more oily tallow lather but the main characteristics of the original are still there.
Lastly is the "premium" formula. This uses shea butter, coconut oil & glycerin. For me it's on-par with MdC, probably better even. However, if you favour US artisans soaps you still won't like this one.
Premium scents are: Rose de Pushkar, Vetiver, Oud/Neroli, Bay Rum & Narcisse.
So in summary, you have only tried the bad one's
BUT, if you enjoy US tallow soaps (which I think you do?) then you will probably not find much to love in any LPL soap and should save your money for something else.