Those English creams, worth the money?

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
Over here The Body Shop constantly runs sales so you virtually never pay full price. Right now their Maca Root & Aloe shave cream 200 ml is on for $11.70 CAD instead of $18.00 CAD. At the other end of the scale Castle Forbes would cost me $60.00 CAD for 200 ml. At the lower end of the scale Ingram's would be $6.75 for 100 ml and Erasmic $7.85 CAD for 75 ml. All from online.

I think the Maca Root & Aloe is a new version of their shave cream as previously it was simply called Maca Root. The old version is closing out at $3.00 CAD for 125 ml. online.

Bob
Bob, thanks for the tip. I’ll be off to my local Body Shop later this morning to pick up a tub of the new Maca Root shaving cream and a tube of the old Maca Root shaving cream along with a stick of the Maca Root men’s deodorant.
The on-line offer of 35% is available in-store as well. I just hope the store has stock.
 
D

Deleted member 1881

Guest
Bob, thanks for the tip. I’ll be off to my local Body Shop later this morning to pick up a tub of the new Maca Root shaving cream and a tube of the old Maca Root shaving cream along with a stick of the Maca Root men’s deodorant.
The on-line offer of 35% is available in-store as well. I just hope the store has stock.

Don't make the mistake and buy the new Maca Root Aloe Vera version. You will search for the old tub 200gr.

@MntnMan62 can confirm.
 

R181

Grumpy old man
Bob, thanks for the tip. I’ll be off to my local Body Shop later this morning to pick up a tub of the new Maca Root shaving cream and a tube of the old Maca Root shaving cream along with a stick of the Maca Root men’s deodorant.
The on-line offer of 35% is available in-store as well. I just hope the store has stock.
Good luck finding the old Maca Root shave cream in store. They were out of it local a while ago. If you get the new Maca Root & Aloe let us know how it compares with the old plain Maca Root stuff.

Bob
 

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
Good luck finding the old Maca Root shave cream in store. They were out of it local a while ago. If you get the new Maca Root & Aloe let us know how it compares with the old plain Maca Root stuff.

Bob
Yup, a tube of the old Maca Root not insight. I did buy a tub of the new Maca Root & Aloe and will let you know how it compares with the old. What ticked me off in the store was the staff seemed unaware of the 35% offer; I had to have them check on-line and, of course, it was...not good.
 

R181

Grumpy old man
Yup, a tube of the old Maca Root not insight. I did buy a tub of the new Maca Root & Aloe and will let you know how it compares with the old. What ticked me off in the store was the staff seemed unaware of the 35% offer; I had to have them check on-line and, of course, it was...not good.
Just trundled off to my local Body Shop store and bought the new Maca Root & Aloe 200 ml. At the store they knew it was 35% off so got mine for the $11.70. Did a hand lather with an Omega boar brush when I got home to see what the hubbub was about. Seemed to hand lather like the old stuff and was slick as snot to boot. Will be using it in tomorrow mornings shave and will comment in this thread https://www.atgshaving.com/threads/body-shop-maca-root-shave-cream-old-vs-new.11081/ on it then.

Bob
 
D

Deleted member 1881

Guest
What’s the issue with the new Maca Root & Aloe? At the price I couldn’t resist it.
Not as good as the old Maca. Good price but definitely not as slick as the old one.

The residual slickness of the old one is phenomenal for a cream. It behaves like an expensive soap.
 

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
Not as good as the old Maca. Good price but definitely not as slick as the old one.

The residual slickness of the old one is phenomenal for a cream. It behaves like an expensive soap.
The proof of the cream is in the shave: I’ll give it a whirl tomorrow and compare notes with Bob’s in the thread he mentioned. Unfortunately I can’t make a side-by-side comparison with the old cream as I used up my old stuff about two months ago.
 

MntnMan62

Forum GOD!
Don't make the mistake and buy the new Maca Root Aloe Vera version. You will search for the old tub 200gr.

@MntnMan62 can confirm.
I have a pretty full opened tub of the original Maca Root and was able to buy another one before they disappeared. I haven't tried the new "Aloe" formulation so can't comment on which is better. But I will say that the one that does not have "Aloe" in the name is very very good. It is one of my favorite creams.
 
D

Deleted member 1881

Guest
The proof of the cream is in the shave: I’ll give it a whirl tomorrow and compare notes with Bob’s in the thread he mentioned. Unfortunately I can’t make a side-by-side comparison with the old cream as I used up my old stuff about two months ago.

I'm waiting for this, man!
 

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
I'm waiting for this, man!
Used it this morning and it seems little changed from the old. It makes a good thick lather with plenty of slickness and cushioning; no irritation at all. It still smells the same. As I pointed out earlier, I am not able to make a side-by-side comparison with the old unfortunately. I’ll continue to use this cream to see more fully how it performs, but my first impression is very good.
 
D

Deleted member 1881

Guest
Used it this morning and it seems little changed from the old. It makes a good thick lather with plenty of slickness and cushioning; no irritation at all. It still smells the same. As I pointed out earlier, I am not able to make a side-by-side comparison with the old unfortunately. I’ll continue to use this cream to see more fully how it performs, but my first impression is very good.

Glad to hear this, the old one is discontinued in Greece and I only have a full tub of it so it is good that I have this new Aloe Vera option.

@Do you hear @MntnMan62?
 

R181

Grumpy old man
Used it this morning and it seems little changed from the old. It makes a good thick lather with plenty of slickness and cushioning; no irritation at all. It still smells the same. As I pointed out earlier, I am not able to make a side-by-side comparison with the old unfortunately. I’ll continue to use this cream to see more fully how it performs, but my first impression is very good.
The same impression after using it this morning. My comments are posted in the old vs new Maca Root thread.

Bob
 
D

Deleted member 1881

Guest
The same impression after using it this morning. My comments are posted in the old vs new Maca Root thread.

Bob

I've read them too, great writing!

Keep posting your next shaves with it gents!

How was the residual slickness? Were you able to go for another quick pass on some areas without lather?
 
Top