I get why you're using all those products and you're quite clear that you can see the benefits ... carry on.
If you can simplify, great. If there's something else to add ... do so.
For me, I have oily skin and this time of year is hell for me - it's warm and humid. Urgh!
I shave daily. Single pass.
I wash well with hot water to remove the soap. Cold water splash and splash/hold. While still wet, apply alum. Pat dry.
Rinse off with witch hazel - I use neat, you use Thayers. Yeah, creaking clean!
Splash/hold with cold water.
Aftershave - the more alcoholic the better. I'll even apply a little alum again while still wet just to problematic areas.
Some folks will want to treat key areas, like eyes or nose. Specific products.
Personally, I'd like to simplify that to just hot rinse, cold rinse, pat and aftershave but with oily skin, I have to dry it out. Especially with modern soaps which are all "feedy", I have to get all that feeding oils back out of my skin and alum is good to do that, witch hazel works well and highly alcoholic splashes seem to work well.
... or use an old-fashioned soap, like MWF. Then I can just rinse off and aftershave.
Hmmm ... maybe it's more in the pre-shave and the soap? Thoughts?