@DesertIguana, you answered your own question, “how could this be?”
Only Badger I ever had was Black Badge, it was cheeped..No Back Bone, Collapse like house of cards.....could not Scrub worth a dam,
Almost every new traditional shaver asks the same question. You’ve been around the block once or twice and should have seen for yourself by now that you get what you pay for. The category doesn’t matter. Cars, instruments, food, audio, alcohol, furniture… the list is huge; it goes on forever. Yes, you’re right! Inexpensive brushes made with black badger hair are by their very nature (i.e., cheaply and quickly made) floppy and definitely not scrubby. In general, they suck wind. The best you’ll get from that brush is scritch, not scrub

If one seriously wants to understand the visual and functional beauty of a finely made brush with a top quality badger knot, one must experience it in hand and on face. It’s a luxurious feeling that many here among us find very appealing and pleasing. Now, mind you, I also enjoy using a select few boar bristle shave brushes. I went through many to find examples that make me happy. And you wanna know what? Here too, you get what you pay for. Even in regards to boar brushes more money almost always buys a higher quality knot and a better quality handle.
Think about it like this. You like cigars (they’re not my bag, btw). You‘ve said yourself in other threads that you prefer a better quality cigar over a cheaper one. I’ve never smoked a high quality cigar and don’t know the finer points of distinguishing between lesser and better quality cigars. The same thing applies to wet shaving. Some of us have developed an appreciation for and enjoy a little slice of daily life that makes us happy when engaged in an activity as mundane as shaving our whiskers. Get it?