TOBS shaving creams

Steve

Boomer Member
I've only used one vintage Coates cream for comparison which didn't particularly wow me. I'd say they latest formulations are perfectly adequate but may require more product per shave as they seem to be less concentrated than the creams of last century.
Still writing for The Strand, and living at 221B Baker St., Dr. Watson?
 

Sausage

Forum GOD!
I have got better results with TOBS lately. The key has been to put bigger amounts of TOBS than I used to do ( not peanut size... MORE!) to shaving bowl and add water little by little.
—> better results
 

Dr Watson

James
Absolutely, it's cheap enough to use a good dollop each shave.

I do wonder if there's been a reformulation recently? I purchased a tub of Sandalwood cream directly from TOBS and it's a little different to previous tubs I've had... The cream is brilliant white whereas I remember previous one's having a brown tint? It's very firm, more like a Razorock croap than traditional cream. Also the scent, while instantly recognisable as TOBS Sandalwood it's less spicy and more soapy. Maybe it's just batch variation.
 

Dr Watson

James
Agree - my latest tub is firmer than I remember. I thought it was just that it had gotten really cold on the doorstep, but at room temperature it is still a lot firmer than it used to be.
My tub of Avocado (ordered at the same time) is the same but having never used that before I couldn't say if it's changed. Now I think about it these are the same consistency as Trumper & T&H creams, firm and dense. In the past my TOBS creams have all been quite runny.
 

J-B-M

Forum GOD!
Does sound like reformulation of some kind. And I agree TOBs sandalwood was my first ever traditional shaving software and back then it definitely had a coffee tint.
 

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
Absolutely, it's cheap enough to use a good dollop each shave.

I do wonder if there's been a reformulation recently? I purchased a tub of Sandalwood cream directly from TOBS and it's a little different to previous tubs I've had... The cream is brilliant white whereas I remember previous one's having a brown tint? It's very firm, more like a Razorock croap than traditional cream. Also the scent, while instantly recognisable as TOBS Sandalwood it's less spicy and more soapy. Maybe it's just batch variation.
This is the question I posed when I started this thread; see my post #1.
 

Dr Watson

James
This is the question I posed when I started this thread; see my post #1.
Aha, so you did! Although not confirmed by TOBS themselves the current evidence suggests something has changed, be it formulation or manufacturer.

With my new one's I've found performance to be adequate though I remembered them being slicker.
 

Rufusdog

Forum GOD!
Aha, so you did! Although not confirmed by TOBS themselves the current evidence suggests something has changed, be it formulation or manufacturer.

With my new one's I've found performance to be adequate though I remembered them being slicker.
I’ve just received a tub of Eton College shaving cream, which I’ll start using in a fortnight or so once I’ve finished a tub of Fendrihan Aloe Water shaving cream (lovely stuff BTW). After a few uses I’ll revert on how I find the Elton College. I hope I’m not disappointed as I’ve been a die hard user of TOBS shaving creams for the last 25 years.
 

J-B-M

Forum GOD!
Definitely interested to know if it is different base formulas for different creams now. I know some have historically been better than others but I assumed that was simply because of 'flavour' with the actual bases being the same. Now I am wondering if there is more than one manufacturer in place for different creams.
 

Dr Watson

James
I hope I’m not disappointed as I’ve been a die hard user of TOBS shaving creams for the last 25 years.
I think you'll be fine. Just used it for this evenings shave and enjoyed every second... I could happily use nothing but TOBS for the rest of my life (provided I had a good rotation of scents to prevent boredom!)
 
Top