I grew up with Tolkien. I do feel his son has made a career ( and no little money since the various rights were sold for a pittance) scraping together odd fragments to an ever eager audience for another few moments in Middle Earth. I never understood his motivation for writing what is heavily influenced by
Saxon mythology as an English national epic since they didn't have one. HUH? King Arthur? A prof in University claimed that was Welsh. I said no, they have the Mabinogean and the countless historical and literary layers of Arthur are British. He was Lace Curtain Irish-American and didn't even know what the Tain Bo Culliagh was-the twit. You can understand a lot about a people reading their national epics. I am slogging through the Shah Nameh of Persia which makes the Iliad and War and Peace combined read like a Mickey Spillane novel.
I'll probably buy this latest, if only for another churchwarden pipefull in Middle Earth.
FRODO LIVES!