I wonder which razor suits my situation?

qwvb1111

Legendary Member
Hello everyone, I would like to ask about choosing a safety razor or straight razor since I am new to it. This will be a little bit long but please bear with me.

I am asian and unfortunately I have oily and acne prone skin. I am using Gillette skinguard cartridge razor to get a close shave (I don't think I have sensitive skin, I just want to be as gentle as possible). I shave once a week and recently bought a synthetic brush and Proraso shaving soap for lathering.



The beard under the chin and under the sideburns are coarse and dense. Since I shave once a week, there will be 4mm - 5mm of growth, and it usually takes 3 passes to get a close shave even with newly replaced blade. But after that, when I touch the thick beard area, it stings, and I feel like there are still 0.05mm stubble left.

I don't shave 2 or 3 times a week because it's too much of a hassle.

Even with shaving brush + soap re-lathered 2 times for 3 passes + new catridge blade, I still get the symptoms above. I doubt that is related to the brush and soap, so I wonder if the cartridge razor was sharp enough, or if it was really shaving or tearing my beard. Therefore I'm thinking of replacing it with a safety razor, or straight razor.

Muhle R41, Merkur MK34c, Edwin Jagger DE89 etc. are well-known beginner close comb razors but I am afraid those will be too mild for my stubble and will not get me a efficient and close shave, ideally 2 passes. So I am considering open comb razors.

 ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄
My budget is around $65 USD. These are my current choices:


1) Parker Variant open comb   (adjustable so I can control aggresiveness, I just want to get the right razor at 1st trial, no regretting afterwards and buying another one)


2) Muhle R41 open comb   (spec of R41 is said to be standard, made in Germany so quality assured, but can't be adjusted so maybe not aggressive enough for my stubble?)


3) Parker SR1 shavette   (I heard shavette can nick easily, but if it is the most efficient and can get me the most close and clean shave, I don't think I am not capable of it)

For now I tend to choose Parker Variant open comb. Please tell me what you think, should I buy open comb or shavette? Should I shave the other way, like use pre-shave oil? Will close comb be enough? Thanks in advance.
 

Sami

Forum GOD!
I would go with one of these :

Rockwell 6c or 6s depending on budget
Razorock bbs as
Razorock lupo 0.95

Razorock lupo dc (this one has open comb and close comb on same plate)

Razorock mamba 92

You can't go wrong with one of these.

Btw muhle r41 is most definitely not a beginners razor so better leave that one alone for now.
 
Last edited:

qwvb1111

Legendary Member
I would go with one of these :

Rockwell 6c or 6s depending on budget
Razorock bbs as
Razorock lupo 0.95

Razorock lupo dc (this one has open comb and close comb on same plate)

Razorock mamba 92

You can't go wrong with one of these.

Btw muhle r41 is most definitely not a beginners razor so better leave that one alone for now.
Would you tell me more about Razorock razors? Haven't heard of that brand and would like to know why you think that can't ge wrong.
 

Chris

Forum DOG!
Staff member
If you're only shaving once a week an open comb would be your best bet, anything else is going to clog a lot.
 

Sami

Forum GOD!
On second thought i tend to go with the advice Chris gave you an open comb could be better suited in your case perhaps.
 

TobyC

Patriot
If you're only shaving once a week an open comb would be your best bet, anything else is going to clog a lot.
I sometimes go a few days between shaves, and I've found that a razor with a big gaping hole right behind the guard works best. All the hair just slops through the hole unimpeded. Go look at a Micromatic open comb, which clogs easily, and then look at the Clog-Pruf Micromatic, they knew what they were doing.


1713148394530.png


1713148561499.png
 

bartje-p

Forum GOD!
Try a Razorock GC 84 OC. If you want something even more budget friendly, you may consider a RR Sloc, but my first advise would be the GC.
 

Chris

Forum DOG!
Staff member
I sometimes go a few days between shaves, and I've found that a razor with a big gaping hole right behind the guard works best. All the hair just slops through the hole unimpeded. Go look at a Micromatic open comb, which clogs easily, and then look at the Clog-Pruf Micromatic, they knew what they were doing.


View attachment 149537

View attachment 149538
SE isn't a rabbit hole I've gone down, so will bow to superior knowledge on this one.

I will say that I've never managed to clog my Pils though.
 

TobyC

Patriot
SE isn't a rabbit hole I've gone down, so will bow to superior knowledge on this one.

I will say that I've never managed to clog my Pils though.
The Clog-Pruf is amazing, you should try one. The Micromatics were the first TTO razors, and they were built tough, I've never seen a broken one unless it was smashed or stepped on. Smooth and user friendly, a wet shavers dream, It's worth a venture into the world of SE. 👍
 
Top