I have had the Clubman Citrus Musk and it is labelled as an EdC. I used it as an aftershave as it lasts about as long as an aftershave. Very weak as a EdC. I am using 4711 EdC as an aftershave this week for the same reason.I was going to get that one but the bottle doesn't say "aftershave" and some places sell it as cologne. I prefer things intended to be used as aftershave. The same for Clubman Citrus Musk and Clubman Lime Sec, the bottles don't say aftershave.
Bob

